When I was young there was a popular poster. It had a stylized flower and the caption “War is not healthy for children and other living things.” A bit winsome, perhaps, the innocent part of the hippie thing, but true nonetheless.
Indeed, the most compelling argument that the Just War theory can no longer be applied is this: in every war since World War II the number of civilian casualties has greatly exceeded the number of military casualties.
Many, even Catholics, who should know better, lightly dismiss this as “collateral damage”, but this is stretching the meaning beyond anything the framers of the Just War tradition ever dreamed. “Collateral damage” is one of those euphemisms- like “enhanced interrogation” or “products of conception”- that exists to salve the consciences of those who defend what is indefensible if described nakedly. These clinical-sounding words hide raw reality: “collateral damage” means dead children. “Products of conception” means dead babies. “Enhanced interrogation” means torture.
That so many who claim to be “prolife” defend wars which disproportionately kill innocent children is chilling. Such callousness can only come when reality is cloaked in abstraction. Blinded by nationalism and fear, too many are willing to ignore Our Saviour’s clear teaching.
Whatever “love your enemy” means, I am pretty sure that it does not mean killing his children.
Read Full Post »