Archive for March, 2005

The phone call came this morning, a friend letting us know that Terri Schiavo had died.

She did not die during Holy Week, like many of us had expected, but clung to life tenaciously into what the Roman Church calls the Octave of Easter, and what the Byzantine Church calls Bright Week, a time of celebration when it is forbidden to fast, even on Friday. Terri Schiavo, who entered into the suffering of Christ during Holy Week, began her entry into His Resurrection during Bright Week.

So, while sharing in the grief of her family, we must also share in their hope, not only for Terri’s soul, but for the good that can come of her suffering, as the suffering of what in the Russian Church is called a Passion-Bearer, an innocent person unjustly slain. Perhaps one good effect may lie in prolifers finally waking up to the reality of what
this country has become, and waking up to the generally weak response of most of the politicians and religious leaders in whom they had put their trust.

Oddly, at the end it was not Catholic bishops or Evangelical leaders who came to Florida to plead her defense, but the Rev. Jesse Jackson, God bless him. Perhaps this will lead to the Rev. Jackson rethinking things and returning to the antiabortion stance he once held. And perhaps prolifers will question the package deal they have been sold by the Republican Right, which I have always suspected views us as useful idiots.

And perhaps more Americans will wake up to what has become a tyranny of the judiciary, this rule of black-robed ideologues with their mandates and fiats.

But one may be forgiven if one is sceptical about the odds of America waking up at all. If there is unrelieved grieving it should be for this nation, which seems intent on recreating the dystopian science fictions worlds I read about in the novels of my youth. The killing of Theresa Marie Schindler Schiavo has certainly planted a dark seed toward that end.

May God have mercy on us all.

Daniel Nichols

Read Full Post »

No, not us. Michael Schiavo’s attorney, George Felos.

Overview at NRO.

Read an excerpt from his book, Litigation as Spiritual Practice. No, that is not a joke. Not just any litigation–"right to die" litigation:

"Such a deep, dark, silent blue. I stared as far into her eyes as I
could, hoping to sense some glimmer of understanding, some hint of
awareness. The deeper I dove, the darker became the blue, until the
blue became the black of some bottomless lake. ‘Mrs. Browning, do you
want to die … do you want to die?’ I nearly shouted as I continued to
peer into her pools of strikingly beautiful but incognizant blue."

"While standing in the house with the realtor, I knew I would live
there, as improbable as the circumstances made it seem. Believing that
something will happen is not foresight. Rather, it is the actual
experience in the present of something that will occur in the future. … Most times this ‘knowing’ for me is sensed as a feeling. Sometimes I hear it, and sometimes I see it."

Well, we knew this kind of thing was coming, didn’t we?

For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities,
against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world,
against spiritual wickedness in high places.

–Maclin Horton

Read Full Post »

The Storms Are on the Ocean

About the Easter Vigil and a thunderstorm. Totally apolitical.

Maclin Horton

Read Full Post »

In the Falling Dark

…but this is your hour, and the power of darkness.
           –Luke 23:53

At least as far back as the late ’60s, some people on both the left and the right have exhibited a thrill that doesn’t seem entirely unpleasurable at the idea that some kind of apocalypse is at hand, that their opponents have taken some kind of step which at once reveals the true depths of their evil and cements their grasp upon the country. I partook of it as a left-wing student when I heard people scare each other with talk of the secret concentration camps Nixon was preparing for us. It was the thrill of children scaring themselves with ghost stories, and I gradually learned to turn a skeptical eye on that sort of rhetoric and emotion. A tendency toward hysteria is a feature of the American character and therefore of American politics.

Nevertheless, the boy who cried wolf was eventually correct. I don’t think that the almost certainly impending death of Terri Schiavo means that the government is going to start rounding up Christians or implementing a program of euthanasia for the disabled. But I am concerned that we have taken a decisive step in that direction, a step big enough that historians might one day see it as a useful marker, like the burning of the Reichstag, of a decisive change.

We are witnessing the government-ordered starvation of an innocent person. Whatever else may be said about the Schiavo case, that fact cannot be wished or explained away. One of the many choruses agitating for this act has been saying for a week or two now that "this sort of thing happens every day." That’s what they said in arguing for legalized abortion, too. And perhaps it’s true. But people have always done bad things on the sly, and people have always, in difficult circumstances, done, with good intentions, things that are objectively wrong. When we decide that, in the name of consistency, honesty, and efficiency, we are going to declare right that which we formerly believed to be wrong, that permissible (if not compulsory) which was formerly forbidden, we are in a different moral world.

That impulse has been given as the justification for a lot of our moral "progress" in the past thirty years or so. "Oh, it happens all the time, best to bring it out into the open." Well, no, it isn’t best. Prudence is a virtue and we don’t need to adopt the Wahabbist program of purifying society by force of all wrongdoing. But the abortionist belongs in legal darkness, as does the euthanizer.

Daniel Nichols and I have a standing disagreement about whether the U.S. is and has been "in general and on balance a force for good in the world," I taking the affirmative and he the negative. I’m not ready to abandon my position yet, but there is an undeniable potential for our nation to become the blasphemous and obscene empire represented in the Bible by the timeless image of Babylon. And they have achieved a victory.

There are many, many Americans who are simply misinformed and uncomprehending as to what is really going on in the Schiavo case. There are also many–I’m not sure how many, and the answer to that question is very important–who are taking what I can only describe as demonic glee in Terri Schiavo’s execution, and I’m not one to use the word "demonic" casually. Will this be the hour in which the balance tips their way, or will the extraordinary passion aroused among religious people, and indeed those of no religious persuasion who simply understand that it is wrong to kill a disabled person, lead to a definitive repudiation of euthanasia?

Earlier this week I sent my children a link to Fr. Rob Johansen’s compilation of reasons why Terri’s condition should be re-evaluated. I prefaced it with the observation that there was no reason why this should be turning into a liberal-vs.-conservative fight. And we’re seeing unexpected people on both sides–conservatives saying "let her die," and liberals like Tom Harkin, God bless him, standing firm against the killing. The light is flickering but it isn’t out yet. In what other industrialized nation would this case even be controversial?

I really had not intended to post during the Triduum, but the confluence of these events with the Passion of Our Lord has been so haunting that I’ve found it hard to stop thinking about it. The juxtaposition is so obviously full of significance that it hardly needs comment. With that I’m signing off until Sunday.

See this post at Dawn Eden’s for a Chestertonian reflection on the Schiavo case; some good comments from readers as well.

Maclin Horton

Read Full Post »

Who says…

…there is no culture of death . I guess I should warn you that the site is sickening–not in a physically gruesome way, but morally and humanly. (Tip of the hat to The Dawn Patrol.)

Maclin Horton

Read Full Post »

Physical Reactions

I recently heard, on NPR, a professor from a Big Eastern University opining
about the Terri Schiavo case. Yes, he said, there are videos that seemingly show
Ms Schiavo interacting with her parents, smiling when they arrive, and crying
when they leave. The professor insisted that these were mere "physical
reactions", and stated with certainty that Ms Schiavo was, in fact, incapable of
such consciousness.

It occured to me that while the professor appeared to intelligently
articulate an opinion, in fact what I was hearing was really a mere physical
reaction, albeit one colored by ideology, and that he, like many modern
academics, was incapable of rational thought, not to mention moral

It’s like the adulterer caught in the act by his wife: "It’s not what you
think, honey". I mean what are you going to believe? The evidence of your  own
senses? Or the expert from the Big Eastern University?

Daniel Nichols

Read Full Post »

Culture War, or Holland With Nukes?

Moral reasoning, or lack thereof, in the USA .

Maclin Horton

Read Full Post »

Older Posts »