Editing the journal Caelum et Terra was a rewarding experience, but it was also at times a frustrating one. We had Big Ideas, all right. But we always had a small readership. At its peak, we had around 2,000 subscribers. People would sign up after reading a positive review in the Catholic press- we got good reviews in everything from The Wanderer to The Catholic Worker- but most of them did not renew their subscriptions. Many of these folks felt compelled to write letters to the editor, often hostile and sometimes unintentionally funny, explaining just why it was that we were not what they were looking for. We were too Left, too Right, too Catholic, not Catholic enough, too hippie (the phrase “superannuated flower children” stuck in my mind).
But for those who renewed, C&T was a lifeline, a connection to like-minded people. We had an unusually devoted readership. And while we didn’t appear to have much influence on the Church or the world, we did have a big influence on this small band of readers, many of whom took the ideas we wrote about much further than we ourselves did. And they in turn influenced their children , many of whom took these ideas even further.
I think of Jenny Baklinski, nee Hayden, eldest daughter of enthusiastic C&T readers. Her parents were intensive gardeners and soap makers, pioneers of humanure; the mom sewed the family’s clothes. But the dad kept his day job, like most of us. Jenny, on the other hand, is farming 200 acres in Ontario -about as far north as one can possibly farm- with her husband Tim, a couple of brothers, and her small children. She married into a large and close rural family, so her life is rich in the sort of community life that most of us do without. Recently she wrote about protecting their livestock from marauding wolves. Their income is supplemented by the soapmaking she learned at her mother’s knee, and by Tim’s piano teaching.
Or I think of another young man, Luke Dougherty, son of a couple who hosted the Steubenville Caelum et Terra reading circle in the early 90s, and who own a small homestead and a milk cow. Luke married into a farming family in Minnesota; he is a full time farmer and part time handyman. His wife just had their first child and he is apparently a very happy man.
Now I am not saying that one has to be fending off wolves and otherwise living the pioneer life to aspire to the whole sort of life we espoused. Tom Storck’s son Michael is a college professor, but he often bicycles to work, gardens, and has raised chickens.
And last week we had the rare treat of spending time with the Nickelsons, a young family living in Washington state. Sia Nickelson is the daughter of Will and Dru Hoyt, who own a small farm an hour east of here. Will wrote the wonderful article “Into the Rose”, a beautiful meditation on the life of John Muir, for the magazine.
When I first met Sia, in the mid 90s, when her family moved to Ohio from Berkeley, she was 13. I was struck even then by the way she integrated the best of the hippie counterculture with her Catholic faith. T Bone Burnett may have sang that the culture kept all the bad and destroyed all the good, in his song “The Sixties” but Sia did the opposite. She was intent, from an early age, at living life in a beautiful and earthy and spiritually fruitful way. In the years before she married she became an accomplished potter, though with three little boys she hardly has time for much of that now.
Sia’s husband Justin is a fine fellow, and we enjoyed the sort of good conversation that is too rare in my life. I long ago learned to avoid discussion of social doctrine and politics with my coreligionists, as it nearly always ends in total frustration. But Justin is one of those Catholics who considers the Church’s teachings to be more authoritative than any ideology. He is a Catholic radical and one of the few people I have encountered with whom I agree on almost everything. You can hardly imagine what a treat this was.
What’s more, Sia presented us with a copy of a new journal she has published with some friends. It is called Soul Gardening: Thoughts from the Home Front, and it is lovely. It is narrower in focus than Caelum et Terra, a small quarterly for Catholic mothers, but it very much continues the older magazine’s sensibility. First, aesthetically, Soul Gardening is beautiful, with a spare and elegant look and finely rendered line drawings, many by Sia. Secondly, there is the content. There are articles about raising chickens in the city, on liturgical seasons, and on candlelit family prayer. This last is by Mary Pemberton, daughter of Catholic writer, artist and iconographer Michael O’Brien, who once did a cover for us.
Sia is asking a donation of $14 a year for a subscription but will send it to anyone who asks. But I hope you will send a little more than the suggested offering.
While most of the second generation CTers do not share the technophobia that marked the magazine, and are very comfortable with the new media in all its forms, and while the young moms who produce this little gem of a journal began with the Coffee and Diapers blog a few years ago, I think this effort to produce a tangible, real thing you can hold in your hands, a real journal, deserves our support.
You can subscribe and send your donations to: Sia Nickelson, 7314 NE 58th Avenue, Vancouver, WA 98661
The byline of Caelum et Terra was suggested by a friend in Virginia, a former Baptist seminarian who later spent some years in a Zen Buddhist monastery, and who devoted himself to intensive greenhouse gardening and raising free range chickens. However eclectic his background, I am struck now more than ever by the utter aptness of the line he suggested: “The Kingdom of Heaven is as if a man should scatter seed on the ground and should sleep and rise day and night and the seed should sprout and grow, he knows not how”.
—Daniel Nichols

Daniel,
Thank you for writing this piece. It brings back sweet memories of the Caelum et Terra Years. I recall thinking the journal marked the beginning of a movement toward an integrated Catholic culture. Subsequent years have disappointed that hope. “Orthodox” Catholics have become, it seems, even more whittled down to an Americanist right-wing version of the Faith. The Wal Mart world has overwhelmed and crushed us. Your short essay, however, shows that the flame is not entirely extinguished. Perhaps it will spring up again and spark a conflagaration.
These past few months I have come across another sign of hope. My eldest son, Augustin, is a freshman at a certain small Catholic college you know of. His fellow freshmen, he tells me, have spoken disparagingly of Acton Instiute literature they have found in their dormitory. Now, I would expect such a reaction from my son; but, the fact it is coming from other students is perhaps a sign that, despite the Acton glitz and money, the Catholic social orthodoxy is getting through. I attended a seminar at said college in June where we read Wendell Berry, St. Thomas, and De Koninck on the common good. I was very heartened by the event.
My eldest daughter, Clotilde, is a student at Wyoming Catholic College, where the freshman orientation is three weeks in the Wyoming wilderness. The college is inspired by many of the ideas that we all discussed in the pages of Caelum et Terra.
Being a pessimist by temperament, my temptation is to despair. But Christian hope tells us that even from the driest desert, new life can spring. Dare we hope that a movement toward an integral Catholic culture may spring anew in our time? I fear to hope — but maybe for once an old pessimist will be proven wrong. Maybe.
Christopher, regarding your last paragraph–for this I pray. My thanks to both yourself and Daniel May your Christmas be filled with wonder and hope!
Christopher- There is indeed reason for hope. Justin, who is 29, tells me that a lot of his peers share his outlook. He points to certain Catholic websites as evidence other than anecdotal. I have noticed on Mark Shea’s website, “Catholic and Enjoying It” that he, who is more or less on the same page as CT, does not get shouted down when challenging right wing ideology, or criticizing America’s imperial wars and newfound penchant for torture. To be sure there are the predictable ideologues, but they seem in the minority. Perhaps we have just encountered too many Catholic Americanists among our peers; evidently younger Catholics are questioning things in light of their faith.
Someone once said that it takes one generation to destroy a culture but seven to build it. From what I have seen recently of second generation “CT babies”, we are off to a good start.
Yes, Dan this sight and a few cherished friends and family members help all of us not feel so alone. I asked Ben if I could subscribe to Sia’s magazine for Christmas.
I think there are more people in my generation (kids of boomers) who don’t want the isolation, consumerism, and greed of American culture. Unfortuatley not many of them are Catholic but there is hope out there.
May we all continue to grow in Christ.
Oh, and Christopher- Wyoming Catholic College actually quoted me from CT in their original brochure. I was flattered and curious…
There is also a Carmelite monastery in Wyoming that looks fantastic; a lot of good things going on, unimaginable 30 years ago, even if we are stilled plagued by neocon Americanists…
http://www.carmelitemonks.org
I just found this blog a few weeks ago after stumbling on an old CT article by Thomas Storck about putting the Church calendar ahead of the secular calendar (a topic near and dear to my heart). When I saw the article was from a magazine I thought, “This is great, I have to subscribe to this.” Of course right after that I saw that CT isn’t published anymore, but I was to glad to see at least there is this blog. I know many young families at my parish in south Jersey (a diocesan run TLM parish) would be on board with much of what I have read here, and in the old CT articles. Most of us have a garden of some kind, several of us raise chickens (this is my first year) and we are all trying to a better job incorporating the liturgy into our daily lives. There was even serious talk a few years ago about a bunch of families packing up and moving out to the country to live in a Catholic community within walking distance of each other and our chapel. We would love to see the canonization of both Dorothy Day and Dom Gueranger.
I would have been too young to appreciate C&T when it was published, but I wish I would have found it sooner. I look forward to reading more back articles and old posts from this blog. Thank you.
Another nice post Daniel. Thank you and Merry Christmas.
Gentlemen and Mrs. Hatke,
This is good news. Thank you for giving an old pessimist some grounds for hope.
Uncle Danny,
I have finished reading through the 3 issues you gave me when I was at your place a few weeks ago. Thank you; I was delighted, impressed, and more than a little surprised to see so many of the values I have come to hold dear being espoused by professed Christians. I normally think of the church as a supporter (obliviously) of “The Wal-Mart World.” The realization that it doesn’t have to be that way is a refreshing one, to say the least.
And the intellectual greed of which I have often been accused requires me to borrow more old editions. Could I, perhaps?
Happy New Year,
-Brad
Thanks Brad; we started the magaziine with the hopes that we would find other countercultural Christians out there and it worked; a disproportionate number of my friends I found through the magazine.
I’ll bring some more issues to quench your thirst when we visit my mom in a couple of weeks…
Dan – Enjoyed reading this piece. Brought back some nice memories of those days when you were living in Manassas, VA and starting up the magazine.
Yes, Dan…good memories and insights! There is cause for hope as we watch our youngsters sow the seeds of faith and sustainability that we saved. Jenny, Luke, Sia and our Rebecca, too, are creating their own versions of “Caelum et Terra.” Thank you…I almost took it for granted!